Note to users. If you're seeing this message, it means that your browser cannot find this page's style/presentation instructions -- or possibly that you are using a browser that does not support current Web standards. Find out more about why this message is appearing, and what you can do to make your experience of our site the best it can be.


E-Letter responses to:

perspective:
Eörs Szathmáry, Ferenc Jordán, and Csaba Pál
MOLECULAR BIOLOGY AND EVOLUTION:
Can Genes Explain Biological Complexity?

Science 2001; 292: 1315-1316 [Summary] [Full text]
*E-Letters: Submit a response to this article

Published E-Letter responses:

[Read E-Letter] Perhaps
Tom Layloff   (1 June 2001)

Perhaps 1 June 2001
  Top
Tom Layloff,
Chemist
Department of Chemistry, St. Louis University

Respond to this E-Letter:
Re: Perhaps

"Can genes explain biological complexity?" The answer is perhaps. It depends in part on where you start counting genes. If we define the heritable entity to include the entire gene matrix, then the answer is maybe. If we attempt to define the heritable matrix by the "individual" genes, the answer is probably no. As has been recently noted in the daunting series of articles on Wolbachia, the expression of an organism must include contributions not only from the heritable genetic contributions of the parent organism but also other heritable components arising from invasive elements and possibly an array of proteins that help direct the differentiation processes to a viable organism.

As noted in the news article "DNA sequences provide grist for microbiologists" (Science, 19 Feb. 1999, p. 1105) by Elizabeth Pennisi, the bacterium is best known for infecting insects, where they are transmitted from generation to generation through the germ cells. Depending on the species, it can make the host infertile or alter the sex ratio of the offspring, such that only one sex survives. In contrast, in filaria the Wolbachia seem key to fertility, thereby making the worms susceptible to antibiotics that attack the bacteria. The bacteria "seem to have a pretty interesting role in terms of therapy," Slatko reported. So he and his colleagues have decided to sequence a Wolbachia genome, hoping it will lead to new ways to control filarial infections.

...But as consortium members began analyzing the worm's genetic material, "we kept finding bacterial sequences."

Wolbachia live in the cytoplasm of insect cells and apparently do no harm. These endosymbionts do, however, have a startling effect on the reproduction of their insect hosts, which has led biologists to speculate that Wolbachia might contribute to reproductive isolation and the creation of new insect species (speciation). Bordenstein et al. (1) now provide evidence that this indeed may be the case.

This arrangement ensures that Wolbachia (which are passed to offspring only through females) spread rapidly through the host species because uninfected females that mate with infected males cannot produce offspring.

Starting 25 years ago, a few researchers had noticed "dense bodies"--possibly bacteria--in the embryonic and adult tissues of several species. One report even suggested that antibiotics seem to have antiworm effects. But until recently, "that work was not followed up on," says Guiliano.

"If you kill the Wolbachia, you will [eventually] kill the [infected] nematodes" by preventing their reproduction, explains Scott O'Neill, a vector biologist at Yale University in New Haven, Connecticut.


To Advertise     Find Products


Science. ISSN 0036-8075 (print), 1095-9203 (online)