James Glanz
In a paper in yesterday's issue of Nature, a respected Canadian astronomer labels the first apparent discovery of a planet orbiting a sunlike star outside our solar system a case of mistaken identity. He argues that a subtle, periodic signal in the spectrum of the star 51 Pegasi, originally attributed to the gravitational tug of a roughly Jupiter-sized planet, was actually generated by a complex sloshing on the star's surface. The researchers who made the original claim are not conceding, however.