Note to users. If you're seeing this message, it means that your browser cannot find this page's style/presentation instructions -- or possibly that you are using a browser that does not support current Web standards. Find out more about why this message is appearing, and what you can do to make your experience of our site the best it can be.

Site Tools

  • AAAS
  • Subscribe
  • Feedback

Site Search

Search Advanced

Science 19 January 1973:
Vol. 179. no. 4070, pp. 250 - 258
DOI: 10.1126/science.179.4070.250
Prev | Table of Contents | Next

Articles

On Being Sane in Insane Places

D. L. Rosenhan 1

1 Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305

It is clear that we cannot distinguish the sane from the insane in psychiatric hospitals. The hospital itself imposes a special environment in which the meanings of behavior can easily be misunderstood. The consequences to patients hospitalized in such an environment—the powerlessness, depersonalization, segregation, mortification, and self-labeling—seem undoubtedly countertherapeutic.

I do not, even now, understand this problem well enough to perceive solutions. But two matters seem to have some promise. The first concerns the proliferation of community mental health facilities, of crisis intervention centers, of the human potential movement, and of behavior therapies that, for all of their own problems, tend to avoid psychiatric labels, to focus on specific problems and behaviors, and to retain the individual in a relatively non-pejorative environment. Clearly, to the extent that we refrain from sending the distressed to insane places, our impressions of them are less likely to be distorted. (The risk of distorted perceptions, it seems to me, is always present, since we are much more sensitive to an individual's behaviors and verbalizations than we are to the subtle contextual stimuli that often promote them. At issue here is a matter of magnitude. And, as I have shown, the magnitude of distortion is exceedingly high in the extreme context that is a psychiatric hospital.)

The second matter that might prove promising speaks to the need to increase the sensitivity of mental health workers and researchers to the Catch 22 position of psychiatric patients. Simply reading materials in this area will be of help to some such workers and researchers. For others, directly experiencing the impact of psychiatric hospitalization will be of enormous use. Clearly, further research into the social psychology of such total institutions will both facilitate treatment and deepen understanding.

I and the other pseudopatients in the psychiatric setting had distinctly negative reactions. We do not pretend to describe the subjective experiences of true patients. Theirs may be different from ours, particularly with the passage of time and the necessary process of adaptation to one's environment. But we can and do speak to the relatively more objective indices of treatment within the hospital. It could be a mistake, and a very unfortunate one, to consider that what happened to us derived from malice or stupidity on the part of the staff. Quite the contrary, our overwhelming impression of them was of people who really cared, who were committed and who were uncommonly intelligent. Where they failed, as they sometimes did painfully, it would be more accurate to attribute those failures to the environment in which they, too, found themselves than to personal callousness. Their perceptions and behavior were controlled by the situation, rather than being motivated by a malicious disposition. In a more benign environment, one that was less attached to global diagnosis, their behaviors and judgments might have been more benign and effective.


THIS ARTICLE HAS BEEN CITED BY OTHER ARTICLES:
Improving Psychiatric Services Through Mystery Shopping.
A. Lazarus (2009)
Psychiatr Serv 60, 972-973
   Abstract »    Full Text »    PDF »
Introducing Psychiatrists to Qualitative Research: A Guide for Instructors.
R. Whitley (2009)
Acad Psychiatry 33, 252-255
   Full Text »    PDF »
Comment: Effects of Experience on Judgment Accuracy.
J. W. Lichtenberg (2009)
The Counseling Psychologist 37, 410-415
   PDF »
Teaching Critical Thinking in Psychiatric Training: A Role for the Social Sciences.
E. Bromley and J. T. Braslow (2008)
Am J Psychiatry 165, 1396-1401
   Full Text »    PDF »
The Art and Politics of Covert Research: Doing `Situated Ethics' in the Field.
D. Calvey (2008)
Sociology 42, 905-918
   Abstract »    PDF »
How Kraepelinian was Kraepelin? How Kraepelinian are the neo-Kraepelinians?--from Emil Kraepelin to DSM-III..
H. S. Decker (2007)
History of Psychiatry 18, 337-360
   Abstract »    PDF »
The Kraepelinian dichotomy: the twin pillars crumbling?.
T. Greene (2007)
History of Psychiatry 18, 361-379
   Abstract »    PDF »
DSM and the Death of Phenomenology in America: An Example of Unintended Consequences.
N. C. Andreasen (2007)
Schizophr Bull 33, 108-112
   Abstract »    Full Text »    PDF »
Forty-five years of schizophrenia: personal reflections..
M. V. Seeman (2006)
History of Psychiatry 17, 363-373
   Abstract »    PDF »
The Problem of the Psychopharmacologist.
N. Kontos, J. Querques, and O. Freudenreich (2006)
Acad Psychiatry 30, 218-226
   Abstract »    Full Text »    PDF »
Only a Piece of Meat: One Patient's Reflections on Her Eight-Day Hospital Experience.
E. Feder-Alford (2006)
Qualitative Inquiry 12, 596-620
   Abstract »    PDF »
The future of critical psychiatry.
J. Hopton (2006)
Critical Social Policy 26, 57-73
   Abstract »    PDF »
Psychiatry through the Ethnographic Lens.
V. Skultans (2006)
International Journal of Social Psychiatry 52, 73-83
   Abstract »    PDF »
Real-world ethics and nursing research: A response to Martin Johnson.
L. Clarke (2004)
Journal of Research in Nursing 9, 389-391
   PDF »
Hearts of darkness: 'perpetrator history' and why there is no why.
P. A. Roth (2004)
History of the Human Sciences 17, 211-251
   Abstract »    PDF »
Real-world ethics and nursing research.
M. Johnson (2004)
Journal of Research in Nursing 9, 251-261
   Abstract »    PDF »
Pain, Impairment, and Disability in the AMA Guides.
J. P. Robinson, D. C. Turk, and J. D. Loeser (2004)
J. Law Med. Ethics 32, 315-326
   PDF »
Traumatic Stress and the Differential Diagnosis of Malingering.
A. J.W. Taylor (2003)
Traumatology 9, 197-215
   Abstract »    PDF »
The Ethics of Tailoring the Patient's Chart.
J. Dwyer and A. Shih (2003)
Focus 1, 422-426
   Abstract »    Full Text »    PDF »
A Clash of Methodology and Ethics in `Undercover' Social Science.
C. D. Herrera (2003)
Philosophy of the Social Sciences 33, 351-362
   Abstract »    PDF »
Doing Masculinity in a Mental Hospital.
O. Leyser (2003)
Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 32, 336-359
   Abstract »    PDF »
Childhood trauma and hallucinations in bipolar affective disorder: preliminary investigation.
P. HAMMERSLEY, A. DIAS, G. TODD, K. BOWEN-JONES, B. REILLY, and R. P. BENTALL (2003)
The British Journal of Psychiatry 182, 543-547
   Abstract »    Full Text »    PDF »
Researching mental health: Pathology in a postmodern world.
D. Freshwater (2003)
Journal of Research in Nursing 8, 161-172
   Abstract »    PDF »
The limits of psychiatry.
D. Double (2002)
BMJ 324, 900-904
   Full Text »    PDF »
The history of anti-psychiatry: an essay review.
D. B. Double (2002)
History of Psychiatry 13, 231-236
   PDF »
Unobtrusive measurement: using police information for forensic research.
L. J. Alison, B. Snook, and K. L. Stein (2001)
Qualitative Research 1, 241-254
   Abstract »    PDF »
When the Hospital Becomes Home: Visibility, Knowledge, and Power at Nila.
N. MIZRACHI (2001)
Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 30, 209-239
   Abstract »    PDF »
Ethical Practice and the Abuse of Power in Social Responsibility: Leave No Stone Unturned.
J. Roberts (2001)
The British Journal of Psychiatry 178, 187
   Full Text »    PDF »
Malfeasance and Regaining Nursing's Moral Voice and Integrity.
W. K Mohr and S. Horton-Deutsch (2001)
Nursing Ethics 8, 19-35
   Abstract »    PDF »
How Psychiatry Lost Its Way. an Open Letter in Reply To Paul McHugh.
A. Feinstein (2000)
International Journal of Social Psychiatry 46, 232-235
   PDF »
Rethinking Professional Attitudes in Mental Health Settings.
W. K. Mohr (2000)
Qual Health Res 10, 595-611
   Abstract »    PDF »
The Role of Multimedia in Changing First Impression Bias.
K. H. Lim, I. Benbasat, and L. M. Ward (2000)
Information Systems Research 11, 115-136
   Abstract »    PDF »
The Micropolitics of Identity in Adverse Circumstance: A Study of Identity Making in a Total Institution.
D. A. PATERNITI (2000)
Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 29, 93-119
   Abstract »    PDF »
How Non-Diagnostic Listening Led to a Rapid "Recovery" from Paranoid Schizophrenia: What is Wrong with Psychiatry?.
A. Siebert (2000)
Journal of Humanistic Psychology 40, 34-58
   Abstract »    PDF »
Multicultural Assessment:: Reexamination, Reconceptualization, and Practical Application.
C. R. Ridley, L. C. Li, and C. L. Hill (1998)
The Counseling Psychologist 26, 827-910
   Abstract »
The Ethics of Tailoring the Patient's Chart.
J. Dwyer and A. Shih (1998)
Psychiatr Serv 49, 1309-1312
   Abstract »    Full Text »    PDF »
A Bibliography of Mental Patients' Autobiographies: An Update and Classification System.
R. Sommer, J. S. Clifford, and J. C. Norcross (1998)
Am J Psychiatry 155, 1261-1264
   Abstract »    Full Text »
RESISTANCE AMONG EX-PSYCHIATRIC PATIENTS: Expressive and Instrumental Rituals.
N. J. HERMAN and G. R. MUSOLF (1998)
Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 26, 426-449
   Abstract »
The Everyday Experience of Psychiatric the Users' Viewpoint.
R. Letendre (1997)
International Journal of Social Psychiatry 43, 285-297
   Abstract »    PDF »
Encountering People Labeled "Schizophrenic".
A. Kramer and L. A. Buck (1997)
Journal of Humanistic Psychology 37, 12-29
   Abstract »
"BUT NICE GIRLS DON'T GET IT": Women, Symbolic Capital, and the Social Construction of AIDS.
K. A. GROVE, D. P. KELLY, and J. LIU (1997)
Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 26, 317-337
   Abstract »
Seeking Validation: Hypothyroidism and the Chronic Illness Trajectory.
P. J. Milliken and H. C. Northcott (1996)
Qual Health Res 6, 202-223
   Abstract »    PDF »
Working In Partnership: vision or pipe dream?: An evaluation of the 1994 review of mental health nursing.
J. Hopton and D. Glenister (1996)
Critical Social Policy 16, 111-119
   PDF »
Participant observation in a secure unit: Care, conflict and control.
L. Clarke (1996)
Journal of Research in Nursing 1, 431-440
   Abstract »    PDF »
Psychiatric Nursing and Electroconvulsive Therapy.
L. Clarke (1995)
Nursing Ethics 2, 321-331
   Abstract »    PDF »
Puck in the Laboratory: The Construction and Deconstruction of Hoaxlike Deception in Science.
J. Schnabel (1994)
Science Technology Human Values 19, 459-492
   Abstract »    PDF »
The Social and Biological Components of Mental Disorder: Implications for Services: The 1993 Joshua Bierer Memorial Lecture.
B. Sheldon (1994)
International Journal of Social Psychiatry 40, 87-105
   PDF »
Why William James Might be Considered the Founder of the Scientist-Practitioner Model.
G. S. Howard (1993)
The Counseling Psychologist 21, 118-135
   Abstract »
Adolescent Medicine: Batteries Not Included.
V. C. Strasburger (1992)
Clinical Pediatrics 31, 478-480
   PDF »
Politics and Mental Health I.
A. Jablensky (1992)
International Journal of Social Psychiatry 38, 24-29
   Abstract »    PDF »
DANGER AT SEA: Social Hierarchy and Social Solidarity.
J. A. ENCANDELA (1991)
Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 20, 131-156
   Abstract »
The Paradigm Plague: Prevention, Cure, and Inoculation.
R. Holland (1990)
Human Relations 43, 23-48
   Abstract »    PDF »
Assaults Against Residents of a Psychiatric Institution: Residents' History of Abuse.
D. NIBERT, S. COOPER, and M. CROSSMAKER (1989)
J Interpers Violence 4, 342-349
   Abstract »    PDF »
Studying Heroin Retailers: A Research Note.
T. Mieczkowski (1988)
Criminal Justice Review 13, 39-44
SOCIAL CONSTRUCTION OF MARY BETH WHITEHEAD.
M. HARRISON (1987)
Gender Society 1, 300-311
   Abstract »
Mental Illness Assumptions in Civil Commitment Proceedings.
J. A. Holstein (1987)
Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 16, 147-175
   Abstract »
Subjective Factors in the Judgment of Insanity.
R. J. HOMANT and D. B. KENNEDY (1987)
Criminal Justice and Behavior 14, 38-61
   Abstract »
Being and Doing: The Need for Synthesis in Psychotherapy.
J. Schmir (1986)
Affilia 1, 6-21
   Abstract »    PDF »
Culture and Social Support.
W. T. Liu (1986)
Research on Aging 8, 57-83
   Abstract »
Self-Control and Relationship: Toward a Model of Interpersonal Health.
J. Shapiro and D. Shapiro Jr. (1984)
Journal of Humanistic Psychology 24, 91-116
   Abstract »
Impulsive Youthful Offenders: A Multimodal Cognitive Behavioral Treatment Program.
P. C. BOWMAN and S. M. AUERBACH (1982)
Criminal Justice and Behavior 9, 432-454
   Abstract »
Psychiatric Versus Social Factors: An Attempt at Integration.
J. M. Townsend (1982)
Human Relations 35, 785-804
   Abstract »    PDF »
A Reappraisal of Mental Health Education: a Humanistic Approach.
J. Morrison (1979)
Journal of Humanistic Psychology 19, 43-51
   Abstract »
Influence of Experience on Major Clinical Decisions: Training Implications.
A. T. Meyerson, J. Z. Moss, R. Belville, and H. Smith (1979)
Arch Gen Psychiatry 36, 423-427
   Abstract »    PDF »
The Therapeutic Community as a Research Ward: Myths and Facts.
D. L. Braff, J. Bachman, I. D. Glick, and R. Jones (1979)
Arch Gen Psychiatry 36, 355-360
   Abstract »    PDF »
Analyzing Black Coping Styles: A Supplemental Diagnostic System.
J. P. Harrell (1979)
Journal of Black Psychology 5, 99-108
   Abstract »
Reliability of the Group for Advancement of Psychiatry Diagnostic Categories in Child Psychiatry.
J. H. Beitchman, T. E. Dielman, J. R. Landis, R. M. Benson, and P. L. Kemp (1978)
Arch Gen Psychiatry 35, 1461-1466
   Abstract »    PDF »
Epidemiology of Mental Disorders: Emerging Trends in the United States.
M. M. Weissman and G. L. Klerman (1978)
Arch Gen Psychiatry 35, 705-712
   Abstract »    PDF »
Policies and Practices of Psychiatric Case Selection.
R. M. Emerson and M. Pollner (1978)
Work and Occupations 5, 75-96
   Abstract »    PDF »
A Comparison of Voluntary and Committed Psychiatric Patients.
W. R. Gove and T. Fain (1977)
Arch Gen Psychiatry 34, 669-676
   Abstract »    PDF »
Open Dialogue Systems: Humanizing the Designs of Residential Mental Health Programs.
(1977)
Journal of Humanistic Psychology 17, 31-50
Perceptions of the Distribution of Mental Disorder in a South American City: Some Neglected Aspects of the Sociology of Medical Occupations.
M. Micklin and C. A. Leon (1976)
Work and Occupations 3, 273-302
   Abstract »    PDF »
More on Pseudoscience in Science and the Case for Psychiatric Diagnosis: A Critique of D. L. Rosenhan's "On Being Sane in Insane Places" and "The Contextual Nature of Psychiatric Diagnosis".
R. L. Spitzer (1976)
Arch Gen Psychiatry 33, 459-470
   Abstract »    PDF »
Psychiatric labeling in cross-cultural perspective.
J. Murphy (1976)
Science 191, 1019-1028
   PDF »
Drugs for Emotional Disorders: Current Problems.
L. E. Hollister (1975)
JAMA 234, 942-947
   Abstract »    PDF »
Value-Related Effects on Psychiatric Judgment.
J. M. Schwartz and S. I. Abramowitz (1975)
Arch Gen Psychiatry 32, 1525-1529
   Abstract »    PDF »
Labeling Effects in Psychiatric Hospitalization: A Study of Diverging Patterns of Inpatient Self-Labeling Processes.
E. G. Doherty (1975)
Arch Gen Psychiatry 32, 562-568
   Abstract »    PDF »
Pseudopatients and Pseudoresearch.
S. Vaisrub (1975)
JAMA 232, 59
   Abstract »    PDF »
Classification: Purposes, Principles, Progress, Prospects.
R. R. Sokal (1974)
Science 185, 1115-1123
   Abstract »    PDF »
Implications of Recent Trends in Educational Labeling.
S. R. Forness (1974)
J Learn Disabil 7, 445-449
   Abstract »    PDF »
Medical Ethnocentrism and the Treatment of Addiction.
F. B. Glaser (1974)
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol 18, 13-27
   Abstract »
Protection of Privacy and Confidentiality: Unique law protects patient records in a multistate psychiatric information system.
W. J. Curran, H. Kaplan, E. M. Laska, and R. Bank (1973)
Science 182, 797-802
   Abstract »    PDF »
Brain Surgery in Aggressive Epileptics: Social and Ethical Implications.
V. H. Mark and R. Neville (1973)
JAMA 226, 765-772
   Abstract »    PDF »
The Healthy Personality as a Sick Trait.
C. E. Thoresen (1973)
The Counseling Psychologist 4, 51-56
Psychiatric Diagnosis.
P. R. Fleischman, J. V. Israel, W. A. Burr, P. C. S. Hoaken, O. F. Thaler, H. D. Zucker, J. Hanley, M. Ostow, L. R. Lieberman, F. M. Hunter, et al. (1973)
Science 180, 356-369
   PDF »


To Advertise     Find Products

Science. ISSN 0036-8075 (print), 1095-9203 (online)